Nut Butter & Jelly

Products List

Filters

Sort By:

Display Type:
  • Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Old Fashioned Peach Pecan Jam

    Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Old Fashioned Peach Pecan Jam

    $7.86/ea.
    $ 0.44/oz. | 18 oz.

    You owe it to yourself to try the old-fashioned taste of Amish Wedding Foods’ Peach Pecan Jam (18oz) that is “Just Naturally Good.” It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or sweeteners...
    Add to Cart
  • Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.5 oz. Hot Pepper Bacon Jam Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.5 oz. Hot Pepper Bacon Jam
    Florida Made
    Florida Made

    Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.5 oz. Hot Pepper Bacon Jam

    $10.03/ea.
    $ 0.96/oz. | 10.5 oz.

    Roasted red pepper puree, jalapeno peppers and real bacon combine to create an addictive jam. For a quick appetizer, pour over cream cheese and serve with
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Seedless Red Raspberry Jam

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Seedless Red Raspberry Jam

    $6.30/ea.
    $ 0.70/oz. | 9 oz.
    You owe it to yourself to try the old-fashioned taste of Amish Wedding Foods’ Red Raspberry Jam – Seedless (9oz) that is “Just Naturally Good.” It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Peanut Butter Spread

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Peanut Butter Spread

    $7.44/ea.
    $ 0.83/oz. | 9 oz.
    Nice and sweet! Sometimes known as ˜church spread™ among Amish communities. Great on bread, toast, bananas, ice cream and much more….even use it as a dip for sliced apples and pretzel rods...
    Add to Cart
  • Terrapin Ridge Farms 11 oz. Apple Maple Bacon Jam Terrapin Ridge Farms 11 oz. Apple Maple Bacon Jam
    Florida Made
    Florida Made

    Terrapin Ridge Farms 11 oz. Apple Maple Bacon Jam

    $10.03/ea.
    $ 0.91/oz. | 11 oz.

    The blend of flavors including apples, cinnamon, maple, butter and bacon does not get better than this! Insanely delicious as a cheese topper, try on Brie
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned Black Raspberry Jam

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned Black Raspberry Jam

    $8.26/ea.
    $ 0.92/oz. | 9 oz.
    You owe it to yourself to try the old-fashioned taste of Amish Wedding Foods’ Black Raspberry Jam (9oz.) that is “Just Naturally Good.” It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned Jalapeno Jelly

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned Jalapeno Jelly

    $7.42/ea.
    $ 0.82/oz. | 9 oz.
    You owe it to yourself to try the old-fashioned taste of Amish Wedding Foods’ Jalapeno Jelly (9oz) that is “Just Naturally Good.” It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or sweeteners. The...
    Add to Cart
  • Mrs. Miller's 9 oz. Dutch Apple Jam Mrs. Miller's 9 oz. Dutch Apple Jam

    Mrs. Miller's 9 oz. Dutch Apple Jam

    $6.97/ea.
    $ 0.77/oz. | 9 oz.
    Dutch Apple Jam is made with crisp apples and sweet cinnamon spice. This jam is especially tasty on cinnamon rolls and sweet breads. Ingredients sugar, apples, water, pectin, lemon juice,...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Blackberry Jam

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Blackberry Jam

    $7.42/ea.
    $ 0.82/oz. | 9 oz.
      Ingredients:  White grape juice concentrate, blackberries, water, pectin, citric acid. Produced by equipment handling pecans.
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Concord Grape Jelly

    Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Concord Grape Jelly

    $7.86/ea.
    $ 0.44/oz. | 18 oz.
    You owe it to yourself to try the old-fashioned taste of Amish Wedding Foods’ Grape Jelly (9oz) that is ‘Just Naturally Good.’ It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or sweeteners. The...
    Add to Cart
  • Divina 9 oz. Fig Spread Divina 9 oz. Fig Spread

    Divina 9 oz. Fig Spread

    $7.70/ea.
    $ 0.86/oz. | 9 oz.
    Fig is our jam! We simply cannot resist this classic Mediterranean spread paired with our favorite cheese or baked atop Brie. Rich, full notes of caramel, honey and molasses are the perfect balance...
    Choose Options
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned F-R-O-G Jam

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned F-R-O-G Jam

    $6.30/ea.
    $ 0.70/oz. | 9 oz.
    FROG stands for Fig, Raspberry, Orange and Ginger Ingredients Sugar, water, red raspberries, figs, orange peel, pectin, ginger, citric acid. Produced by equipment handling pecans.
    Add to Cart
  • Mrs. Miller's 9 oz. Grape Jam

    Mrs. Miller's 9 oz. Grape Jam

    $6.97/ea.
    $ 0.77/oz. | 9 oz.
    Made with the body and actual fruit of the grape, Mrs. Miller's Homemade Grape Jam provides the rich distinct taste of the grape with the whole fruit taste of the entire grape.  It's distinctive...
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Triple Berry Jam

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Triple Berry Jam

    $6.30/ea.
    $ 0.70/oz. | 9 oz.
      Ingredients:  White grape juice concentrate, blackberries, black raspberries, red raspberries, water, pectin,citric acid. Produced by equipment handling nuts.
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Seedless Blackberry Jam

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Seedless Blackberry Jam

    $6.30/ea.
    $ 0.70/oz. | 9 oz.
      Ingredients:  White grape juice concentrate, blackberries, water, pectin, citric acid. Produced by equipment handling pecans.
    Choose Options
  • Divina 8.5 oz. Kalamata Olive Spread Divina 8.5 oz. Kalamata Olive Spread

    Divina 8.5 oz. Kalamata Olive Spread

    $11.07/ea.
    $ 1.30/oz. | 8.5 oz.
    This mouthwatering tapenade from Greece is prepared traditionally with Kalamata olives, garlic, capers and spices. A favorite of chefs looking to add bright and briny flavor without having to add...
    Choose Options
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Premium Peach Butter

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Premium Peach Butter

    $7.44/ea.
    $ 0.47/oz. | 16 oz.
      Ingredients:   
    Add to Cart
  • Preserved Harvest® 18 oz. Jumbleberry Jam Preserved Harvest® 18 oz. Jumbleberry Jam

    Preserved Harvest® 18 oz. Jumbleberry Jam

    $8.25/ea.
    $ 0.46/oz. | 18 oz.
    Hand-packed in small batches. No artificial colors. At Preserved Harvest, we are dedicated to giving you the most wholesome pantry packers in the market place. We believe in preserving the harvest...
    Add to Cart
  • Terrapin Ridge Farms 11 oz. Balsamic Onion Jam Terrapin Ridge Farms 11 oz. Balsamic Onion Jam
    Florida Made
    Florida Made

    Terrapin Ridge Farms 11 oz. Balsamic Onion Jam

    $10.03/ea.
    $ 0.91/oz. | 11 oz.
    Loads of caramelized onions are slowly cooked with balsamic vinegar and other spices creating a delectable jam. Add deep flavor to burgers, steaks, and gr
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Christmas Jam

    Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Christmas Jam

    $8.25/ea.
    $ 0.46/oz. | 18 oz.
      Ingredients: 
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Elderberry Jelly

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Elderberry Jelly

    $7.42/ea.
    $ 0.82/oz. | 9 oz.
    You owe it to yourself to try the old-fashioned taste of Amish Wedding Foods’ Elderberry Jelly (9oz) that is “Just Naturally Good.” It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or sweeteners...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Cherry Jam

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. No Sugar Added Cherry Jam

    $6.30/ea.
    $ 0.70/oz. | 9 oz.
    It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or sweeteners. The delicious flavor floats out of the jar! Ingredients:  White grape jui
    Add to Cart
  • Gunflint Trail 9 oz. Chokecherry Jelly Gunflint Trail 9 oz. Chokecherry Jelly

    Gunflint Trail 9 oz. Chokecherry Jelly

    $9.89/ea.
    $ 1.10/oz. | 9 oz.

    Wild Chokecherry Jelly captures the bold, tart flavor of sun ripened chokecherries, balanced with just the right touch of sweetness. Its rich, deep taste makes it a perfect complement to toast,...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned Apricot Jam

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned Apricot Jam

    $6.30/ea.
    $ 0.70/oz. | 9 oz.
    You owe it to yourself to try the old-fashioned taste of Amish Wedding Foods’ Apricot Jam (18oz) that is “Just Naturally Good.” It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or sweeteners. The...
    Add to Cart
  • Crofter's® 16.5 oz. Organic Wild Blueberry Jam Crofter's® 16.5 oz. Organic Wild Blueberry Jam

    Crofter's® 16.5 oz. Organic Wild Blueberry Jam

    $8.83/ea.
    $ 0.54/oz. | 16.5 oz.
    After tasting this organic jar you will try to put it on anything and everything. Ever heard of a blueberry dutch baby? Guess we know what you’re having for breakfast. And for dinner. (We’d have...
    Add to Cart
  • Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.5 oz. Hot Pepper Berry Bacon Jam Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.5 oz. Hot Pepper Berry Bacon Jam
    Florida Made
    Florida Made

    Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.5 oz. Hot Pepper Berry Bacon Jam

    $10.03/ea.
    $ 0.96/oz. | 10.5 oz.
    Sweet raspberries and strawberries are mixed with roasted red peppers and real bacon to create the perfect blend of sweet, spicy and smoky.  This mou
    Add to Cart
  • Divina 9 oz. Sour Cherry Spread Divina 9 oz. Sour Cherry Spread

    Divina 9 oz. Sour Cherry Spread

    $7.70/ea.
    $ 0.86/oz. | 9 oz.
    The sour cherry season is fleeting - typically just a few weeks - so we made it our mission to capture the bright, tart/sweet flavor all year-round in our handcrafted Mediterranean jam. Pair with...
    Choose Options
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Pumpkin Butter

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Pumpkin Butter

    $6.02/ea.
    $ 0.38/oz. | 16 oz.
    For prize-winning flavor, serve the perfect spread in Amish Wedding Foods’ Pumpkin Butter (9 oz.). From time-honored Amish recipes to the true care dedicated to every small batch, Amish Wedding...
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Old Fashioned Blueberry Jelly

    Amish Wedding® 18 oz. Old Fashioned Blueberry Jelly

    $7.70/ea.
    $ 0.43/oz. | 18 oz.
    You owe it to yourself to try the old-fashioned taste of Amish Wedding Foods’ Blueberry Jelly (18oz) that is “Just Naturally Good.” It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or sweeteners...
    Add to Cart
  • Blackburn's 18 oz. Grape Jelly Blackburn's 18 oz. Grape Jelly
    -
    -

    Blackburn's 18 oz. Grape Jelly

    $4.48/ea.
    $4.63
    $ 0.25/oz. | 18 oz.
      Ingredients: 
    Add to Cart
  • Biscoff 13.4 oz. Crunchy Cookie Butter Spread

    Biscoff 13.4 oz. Crunchy Cookie Butter Spread

    $9.19/ea.
    $ 0.69/oz. | 13.4 oz.
    Did you think Biscoff stopped with their traditional cookie? Think again — you can have the delectable taste of a Biscoff cookie in butter form with the Biscoff® Crunchy Cookie Butter — making it...
    Add to Cart
  • Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.9 oz. Raspberry Amaretto Jam Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.9 oz. Raspberry Amaretto Jam
    Florida Made
    Florida Made

    Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.9 oz. Raspberry Amaretto Jam

    $10.03/ea.
    $ 0.92/oz. | 10.9 oz.
    Bright, tangy raspberries and the subtle flavor of almonds and vanilla combine to make a delightful and tasty jam. Perfect spread for bagels and cream cheese, p
    Add to Cart
  • Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned Blueberry Jam

    Amish Wedding® 9 oz. Old Fashioned Blueberry Jam

    $6.30/ea.
    $ 0.70/oz. | 9 oz.
    You owe it to yourself to try the old-fashioned taste of Amish Wedding Foods’ Blueberry Jam (9oz) that is “Just Naturally Good.” It is 100% all-natural with no artificial colors or sweeteners. The...
    Add to Cart
  • Crofter's® 16.5 oz. Organic Seedless Blackberry Jam Crofter's® 16.5 oz. Organic Seedless Blackberry Jam

    Crofter's® 16.5 oz. Organic Seedless Blackberry Jam

    $8.83/ea.
    $ 0.54/oz. | 16.5 oz.
    Try a dollop of this velvety fruit spread in your yogurt and you’ll never go back to the days of seed-y jam. Organic blackberries, Fair-Trade cane sugar: you’ll find yourself trying to figure out...
    Add to Cart
  • Grandma's Jam House 16 oz. Homestyle Huckleberry Jam Grandma's Jam House 16 oz. Homestyle Huckleberry Jam

    Grandma's Jam House 16 oz. Homestyle Huckleberry Jam

    $15.65/ea.
    $ 0.98/oz. | 16 oz.
    Indulge in the taste of homemade huckleberry jam made from all-natural ingredients. Grandma's Jam House jam is crafted with the finest huckleberries, cane sugar, water, pectin, and citric acid. We...
    Add to Cart
  • Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.5 oz. Mango Habanero Jam Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.5 oz. Mango Habanero Jam
    Florida Made
    Florida Made

    Terrapin Ridge Farms 10.5 oz. Mango Habanero Jam

    $10.03/ea.
    $ 0.96/oz. | 10.5 oz.
    Delight your palate with this perfect pairing of mellow mangos and feisty habaneros. Spread this gourmet jam on pork, chicken and fish before baking. Mix with a
    Add to Cart
  • Terrapin Ridge Farms 11 oz. Blueberry Bourbon Pecan Jam Terrapin Ridge Farms 11 oz. Blueberry Bourbon Pecan Jam
    Florida Made
    Florida Made

    Terrapin Ridge Farms 11 oz. Blueberry Bourbon Pecan Jam

    $10.45/ea.
    $ 1.02/oz. | 10.2 oz.
    Blueberries bursting with flavor are married with pecans, raisins, cinnamon and a splash of bourbon, creating a jam that is sure to become your favorite. Not on
    Add to Cart
  • Biscoff 14.1 oz. Creamy Cookie Butter Spread

    Biscoff 14.1 oz. Creamy Cookie Butter Spread

    $9.19/ea.
    $ 0.65/oz. | 14.1 oz.
    Lotus Biscoff Cookie Butter is a sweet spread made from original Lotus Biscoff Cookies. Spread it! Dip it! Mix it! Spoon it! Biscoff Cookie Butter is enjoyed in a variety of ways - on a slice of...
    Add to Cart